Tragedy at Columbine
APRIL 20, 1999 - LITTLETON, COLO.

Positive feelings emerge from shooting tragedy

Many say the Columbine killings have changed perspectives

By Pam Regensberg
Camera Staff Writer


LITTLETON — Moments after teenage gunmen mowed down their Columbine High School classmates and a popular teacher, students and residents throughout the state began looking beyond the evil to find a glimmer of hope.

Many agree that optimism is rare these days, but they say they have begun to see a positive change emerge from this tragedy, which took 15 lives and affected countless others.

The barriers that once divided student groups and the city appear to be falling, many say. Trivial things have been replaced by what really matters: family, friends and community.

"Even people you hated in school, you were happy to see them alive," said 14-year-old Laura Green, a Columbine High School freshman who, along with classmates, barricaded herself in the school's choir room during Tuesday's killing spree. "It already has changed me, totally, for the good."

Bethany Urban, 14, who was in the science lab at Columbine, said the mass murder has helped her put life in perspective.

"We're a lot closer, me and my family," Urban said, adding that it has been especially touching to see the outpouring of support and encouragement from strangers.

Crude shrines on the northeast corner of Clement Park, adjacent to the high school, show a city, state, nation and world pulling together.

Well-wishers from as far away as Australia paid tribute to the dead and injured with cards, flowers and blue ribbons.

On Saturday, a steady stream of sympathizers solemnly walked past the now soggy and muddied memorials. Some wept. Others embraced their loved ones. All were quiet.

"There's a rule in my house: hugs and kisses every morning," said Noah Renova, a 36-year-old Brighton father of two girls. "Now, it's twice a day and at night."

Renova said the suffering in Littleton moved his family so much that he has vowed to cherish every waking moment he has with his daughters, 12-year-old Brandy Ash and 6-month-old Adrianna.

"There's more 'I love you,' " Renova said while cradling his infant daughter.

A 17-year-old self-described "stoner," Josh Nielsen of Columbine said the slayings ended a long-standing rivalry between his friends and the jocks.

"It had been a big jock-stoner brawl," Nielsen said, wearing a tattered black-leather jacket.

The battling, however, ended with the deaths of their classmates and teacher, William "Dave" Sanders.

At a Thursday night vigil, anathlete "just came up to me at the church and said 'We're cool,' " Nielsen said. "It had hit me really hard. I just broke down.

"Everybody is sorry for the differences they had."

Such improved feelings toward others were not universal, however. A caller to a Denver radio station last week after the massacre said he saw three Subway restaurant patrons harassing a young man who was wearing a black trench coat, similar to the garments worn by the killers.

On the Colorado State University campus in Fort Collins, the school violence in the Denver suburb left some college students longing for family.

"For the first time I'm calling my parents trying to get a hold of them," said CSU junior Brett Nolan, 20, who attended Pomona High School in Arvada. "I've called everyday."

Nolan said the calling home isn't going to stop anytime soon.

Kathy Malley, 50, of Littleton didn't know about the rampage at Columbine until friends and family members from six different states called to make sure her teen-age son was OK.

Though Malley's 14-year-old son, Skyler, did not attend Columbine High, she is still reluctant to let him out of her sight. But she admits that she is comforted by the cohesive relationships that have grown out of the massacre.

"It's encouraging to see how the community has come together," the stay-at-home mother said.

April 25, 1999

  BoulderNews

  BACKGROUND
Full index of the shooting main page
Reconstruction of the shooting full story
Timeline
Location the school
Floorplan
Weapons used

  AUDIO
'Friend of Mine'
Listen to the Columbine Memorial song sung by Columbine students Jonathan and Stephen Cohen.

911 tapes
Student - Audio/Transcript
SWAT team rescue - Video

Interview with Arun Ghandi
Arun Ghandi, one of Ghandi's grandsons, speaks to Boulder County students about his non-violence campaign and his thoughts on Columbine. Interview


  PHOTOS
A Daily Camera photo essay detailed the tragedy of April 20 and the recovery and remembrance in the following weeks: photo essay

  INTERACT
In light of the shooting on April 20, should the state legislature allow people to carry concealed weapons? vote here
With the recent rise in school violence, do you feel schools are still safe? vote here

  THE VICTIMS
Cassie Bernall
Steven Curnow
Corey DePooter
Kelly Fleming
Matthew Kechter
Daniel Mauser
Daniel Rohrbough
William "Dave" Sanders
Rachel Scott
Isaiah Shoels
John Tomlin
Lauren Townsend
Kyle Velasquez

  THE INVESTIGATION
Gunmen paid for weapons, teenager claims full story
CHS investigators focus on computers full story
Investigators try to disprove third CHS shooter full story
Man charged with selling handgun to child full story
FBI investigator's son linked to case full story
Agents creating models of Columbine full story
Teen targeted by sheriff denies involvement in school attack full story
Arrest in Columbine shooting full story
Killer reportedly took Luvox antidepressant full story
Officials no closer to arresting suspects full story
Detectives question shooter's girlfriend full story
Security videotapes at school may show whether gunmen had help full story
Bombs found in cafeteria full story
Portraits of the killers full story
Killer's diary describes plot of hate full story

  SCHOOL VIOLENCE
Violence in Georgia full story
School violence stuns nation full story
Teen wounds six fellow students full story
Teens charged in alleged school attack plot full story
Michigan teenagers charged in plot full story
Other school shootings full story
1927 school bombing killed nearly 40 children full story
Suspensions, arrests across country full story
La. school site of another shooting full story
Facts: Death in schools full story
'Blood in the School Yard', from the Cincinnati Post full series

  REACTION
High schools' 'cult of the athlete' under scrutiny full story
Parents of Columbine shooters sued full story
Suit planned against parents of Columbine High shooters full story
Columbine spurs interest in home schools full story
Columbine healing fund raises $2.3 million full story
Safe Night aims to curb youth violence full story
CU frat shows support for Columbine full story
'Healing bear' arrives to help in Littleton full story
Doctors: Guilt a normal reaction for survivors full story
School security business surges full story
Media the message? full story
Broomfield couple campaigns to 'Erase the Hate' full story
Clint Talbott - BVSD rejects dress code column
What now? editorial
Video of Clinton's Wednesday morning speech
Video of Clinton's Tuesday speech


  GUNS AND LAW
GOP tinkers further with gun legislation full story
Columbine dad lobbies Washington full story
Group forms to back gun control full story
Poll says two-thirds in U.S. support tougher restrictions on guns full story
Senate passes more gun controls full story
Columbine killers also wounded the NRA full story
Senate rejects any new restrictions on gun-show sales full story
Dems want special session full story
Gun control strife full story
House won't debate gun bill full story
New gun laws on table full story
Leaders scrap gun bills full story
Guns and legislatures full story

  HOW TO HELP
- The Denver Rocky Mountain News has established a drive to raise money for a memorial to the victims of the Columbine High School tragedy. Contributions may be mailed to the Columbine Memorial Fund, c/o The Jefferson Foundation, 809 Quail St., Building 1, Lakewood, CO 80215.

Memorial Funds
Donate
Family Assistance
Counseling Services